Turkey and Cheese Reindeer Sandwich (Cute Christmas Lunch for Kids)

These Turkey and Cheese Reindeer Sandwiches are a fun, festive lunch for kids. Easy, quick, and adorable — perfect for holiday parties or lunchboxes.

This post may contain affiliate links. I will receive a small commission from these sales at no additional cost to you!

Turkey and Cheese Reindeer Sandwich

Hey mama! If you’re looking for a quick holiday lunch that looks like you spent ages on it (but actually takes 10 minutes), this Turkey and Cheese Reindeer Sandwich is your new festive go-to. It’s simple, adorable, and guaranteed to make your kids grin.

We’re talking everyday ingredients magically transformed into a cute Rudolph-style sandwich — perfect for lunchboxes, school parties, or a fun December afternoon.

A little creativity, a cookie cutter, and boom… holiday magic on a plate.

Ingredients needed

Supplies You’ll Need

How to Make Reindeer Sandwiches

1. Slice off the stem-marked end of each cherry tomato and discard.
2. Cut each olive in half, keeping the halves with the solid center hole (these make the best “eyes”).
3. Lay out two slices of bread with the rounded side facing you.
4. Add a slice of cheddar cheese on each piece of bread.
5. Fold the turkey slices in half and layer them evenly over the cheese.

1. Add the top slices of bread.
2. Use a heart cookie cutter to cut out the sandwich shape. Keep or snack on the scraps.

1. Add the reindeer face: place a cherry tomato at the bottom point for the nose, then two olive “eyes” just above and slightly apart.
2. Gently tuck a pretzel into each side of the sandwich between the bread layers to form antlers.
3. Serve and enjoy!

Serving Ideas

• Lunchbox idea: Pack with grapes, carrot sticks, or holiday trail mix.
• Party platter: Make 6–8 and line them up as a little reindeer herd.
• Snack pairing: Serve with hot cocoa or your Rudolph Chocolate Bark.
• After-school treat: Perfect for December afternoons before homework.

How to Store

• Refrigerate: Store assembled sandwiches in an airtight container for up to 24 hours.
• Keep pretzels crisp: Add pretzels right before serving.
• Prep ahead: Cut the olives and tomatoes the night before to save time.

FAQs

Can I make these sandwiches the night before? Yes, leave the pretzels off until right before serving so they don’t soften.

What can I use instead of a cherry tomato for the nose? A strawberry slice, red bell pepper, or even a grape works great.

Can I use a different cookie cutter? Yes! Any shape that comes to a point at the bottom can make a cute reindeer face.

Can this be dairy-free or gluten-free? Absolutely — swap in dairy-free cheese or gluten-free bread/pretzels.

Will this work with different meats or cheeses? Yep! Ham, Swiss, mozzarella, or whatever your kids love.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• Fast and festive. Looks impressive, but takes just a few minutes.
• Kid-approved. Even picky eaters get excited about a cute reindeer face.
• Simple ingredients. Bread, turkey, cheese — things you already have.
• Holiday party favorite. Great for December playdates or school lunches.
• Customizable. Swap meats, cheeses, or bread, and it still works.

One Last Thing

Sometimes the smallest touches really do make the biggest difference in our kids’ day, and this adorable Turkey and Cheese Reindeer Sandwich is one of those easy wins. Whether you pop it into a lunchbox, serve it after school, or make it together on a December afternoon, it’s guaranteed to bring smiles.

More Family Favorite Christmas Recipes